Revision history [back]

hello;

I just started trying sage to test Fricas integrate, but for some results, it fails, even though Fricas actually is able to do the integration.

It fails because it can't translate Fricase result to sage, so it gives an exception. I record this as failed integrate, since for any exception thrown, I assume it failed. But this is not fair for Fricas since it actually did not fail.

Here is an example

   sage: var('t, n')
   anti=integrate(log(t)^(-n - 1),t, algorithm="fricas")

exception trapped is

NotImplementedError: The translation of the FriCAS  
Expression cos((n+1)*pi )*Gamma((-1)*n,(-1)*log(t)) to sage is not yet implemented.

Why it can't translate it, since Maxima result has a gamma in it. Is it the UpperCase Gamma that is the problem?

    integrate(log(t)^(-n - 1),t, algorithm="maxima")
     -(-log(t))^n*log(t)^(-n)*gamma(-n, -log(t))

No error. I am using

      SageMath version 8.3.beta5, Release Date: 2018-06-09

hello;

I just started trying sage to test Fricas integrate, but for some results, it fails, even though Fricas actually is able to do the integration.

It fails because it can't translate Fricase result to sage, so it gives an exception. I record this as failed integrate, since for any exception thrown, I assume it failed. But this is not fair for Fricas since it actually did not fail.

Here is an example

   sage: var('t, n')
   anti=integrate(log(t)^(-n - 1),t, algorithm="fricas")

exception trapped is

NotImplementedError: The translation of the FriCAS  
Expression cos((n+1)*pi )*Gamma((-1)*n,(-1)*log(t)) to sage is not yet implemented.

Why it can't translate it, since Maxima result has a gamma in it. Is it the UpperCase Gamma that is the problem?

    integrate(log(t)^(-n - 1),t, algorithm="maxima")
     -(-log(t))^n*log(t)^(-n)*gamma(-n, -log(t))

No error. I am using

      SageMath version 8.3.beta5, Release Date: 2018-06-09

     FriCAS Computer Algebra System 
                        Version: FriCAS 1.3.3
               Timestamp: Sun Jun 17 01:20:37 CDT 2018

      (1) -> integrate(log(t)^(-n - 1),t)

             (1)  cos((n + 1)%pi)Gamma(- n,- log(t))
                                     Type: Union(Expression(Integer),...)

hello;

I just started trying sage to test Fricas integrate, but for some results, it fails, even though Fricas actually is able to do the integration.

It fails because it can't translate Fricase Fricas result to sage, sage syntax, so it gives an exception. I record this as failed integrate, since for any exception thrown, I assume it failed. But this is not fair for Fricas since it actually did not fail.

Here is an example

   sage: var('t, n')
   anti=integrate(log(t)^(-n - 1),t, algorithm="fricas")

exception trapped is

NotImplementedError: The translation of the FriCAS  
Expression cos((n+1)*pi )*Gamma((-1)*n,(-1)*log(t)) to sage is not yet implemented.

Why it can't translate it, since Maxima result has a gamma in it. Is it the UpperCase Gamma that is the problem?

    integrate(log(t)^(-n - 1),t, algorithm="maxima")
     -(-log(t))^n*log(t)^(-n)*gamma(-n, -log(t))

No error. I am using

      SageMath version 8.3.beta5, Release Date: 2018-06-09

ps. Output from Fricas itself matches what is shown above OK.

     FriCAS Computer Algebra System 
                        Version: FriCAS 1.3.3
               Timestamp: Sun Jun 17 01:20:37 CDT 2018

      (1) -> integrate(log(t)^(-n - 1),t)

             (1)  cos((n + 1)%pi)Gamma(- n,- log(t))
                                     Type: Union(Expression(Integer),...)