When I plot a sine and parabola I get two obvious intersections
plot(x^2-5,-10,10,ymax=20) + plot(sin(x),-10,10)But when I solve to get the two numeric x values, the answer makes no sense.
solve(x^2-5==sin(x),x)
[x == -sqrt(sin(x) + 5), x == sqrt(sin(x) + 5)]
It makes sense: it tried to solve symbolically, and it didn't get very far (it isolated the square, and took ± the square root).
You don't want to solve symbolically but numerically. You want to find the two real zeros of x^2 - 5 - sin(x), and from the picture you (roughly) know intervals where these are located, so you can use find_root:
sage: find_root(x^2 - 5 - sin(x), -5, 0)
-2.025211637444818
sage: find_root(x^2 - 5 - sin(x), 0, 5)
2.3846766601465696Thanks. Although it's odd that plot can "solve" it but solve cannot. Maybe in a future iteration of sagemath, a symbolic failure will default to find_root.
Can you only get this numerically or is there some form of advanced math that could solve a trig/algebra equivalence? I couldn't think of a way to do it by hand.
Most equations have no clean solution and must be evaluated with numerical approximations. This is one of them. Even polynomials can cause problems.
Asked: 4 years ago
Seen: 322 times
Last updated: Oct 18 '20
Copyright Sage, 2010. Some rights reserved under creative commons license. Content on this site is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution Share Alike 3.0 license.
